Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stephen Bainbridge's avatar

I basically agree. Certainly with the central thesis, if not with all the precise details. But it's point # 16 that grabs me the most. Given our interconnected world, I wonder--indeed, doubt--whether a national AI regulator will suffice. I keep reading that China's AI companies are 6-12 months behind the US. Other. nations are working on AI, as well. Without agreed upon and enforced global guardrails, a domestic regulator seems more likely to simply retard US development of AI while leaving the world vulnerable to whatever comes out of foreign labs.

Jon's avatar

Not one of Cass's better ideas. Unless there is some high-profile focussing event that changes the politics, there is no realistic prospect that a new federal regulatory commission can be created by Congress and up and running in less than several years. Given the speed of AI development, the cows are likely to be long gone before the barn door is shut. Staffing such an agency with people who know what they are doing would be very difficult, given the difference between government and industry pay scales. For better or worse, the response of the federal government to AI will have to come from existing agencies like OMB, Commerce, CAISI, and the FTC. Of course, if you want to freeze AI development in the U.S., NRC-style regulation is the way to go. The NRC either saved us from another Chernobyl or blocked a fix for Global Warming. Opinions differ.

1 more comment...

Ready for more?